Why Court Rejected Atiku’s Fresh Evidence In Suit To Disqualify Tinubu From 2027 Race

0
141

The Federal High Court in Abuja has dismissed an application by former Vice President Atiku Abubakar and the African Democratic Congress (ADC) seeking to introduce fresh evidence in their suit challenging President Bola Tinubu’s eligibility to contest the 2027 presidential election.

Justice Inyang Ekwo, who delivered the ruling on Friday, held that allowing the plaintiffs to introduce new exhibits outside the constitutionally prescribed period would violate Section 285(9) of the 1999 Constitution, which requires pre-election matters to be instituted within 14 days of the occurrence of the event being challenged.

The judge agreed with arguments by Tinubu and other defendants that the proposed amendment went beyond correcting or modifying the existing case, as it sought to replace evidence already filed with fresh exhibits.

Justice Ekwo consequently ruled that granting the application would fundamentally alter the nature of the suit and occasion injustice to the defendants.

In rejecting the application, the judge accused Atiku of attempting to mislead the court by suggesting that the proposed amendment would not introduce fresh issues.

He said a careful examination of the application showed that the plaintiffs intended to substitute existing evidence with new exhibits, an attempt he considered inconsistent with the constitutional limitation governing pre-election disputes.

“This is a time-bound suit and the law makes it mandatory for all exhibits to be filed in court within 14 days of occurrence of the event being challenged. Anything outside the prescribed 14 days is null and void and of no effect,” Justice Ekwo held.

The judge added: “I find no merit in this application to bring fresh exhibit. It is hereby refused for being against the express provision of the law.”
He subsequently dismissed the application.

The ruling followed a motion on notice filed by Atiku and the ADC on September 10, seeking permission to amend their originating summons against Tinubu, the All Progressives Congress (APC) and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC).

The plaintiffs had indicated their intention to make substantial amendments to their case, which seeks to stop Tinubu and the APC from participating in the 2027 presidential election over allegations surrounding the president’s National Youth Service Corps (NYSC) discharge certificate.

In the substantive suit, marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1888/2026, Atiku and the ADC alleged that the APC submitted a forged NYSC discharge certificate belonging to Tinubu to INEC.

They asked the court to compel the electoral commission to remove Tinubu’s name and that of the APC from the list of candidates and political parties for the 2027 presidential election.

However, Tinubu and the APC, in a joint counter-affidavit filed on September 9, urged the court to dismiss the suit for lacking merit and competence.

The defendants denied submitting any forged certificate to INEC for either the 2023 or 2027 presidential elections.

Through the APC Director of Legal Services, Mr Sanusi Samaila, they also maintained that they did not submit Form CF001 to INEC for either election, contrary to the plaintiffs’ allegations.
They further argued that the NYSC had never disowned the discharge certificate issued to Tinubu at the end of his service year.

According to the defendants, the established legal requirement for proving that a certificate was forged is a disclaimer from the institution alleged to have issued it.

They cited a previous Supreme Court decision in support of their argument and urged the court to uphold their preliminary objection.
INEC had also challenged the competence of the suit in a preliminary objection filed on September 7 through its counsel, Dr Alex Izinyon, SAN.

The commission argued that the action was statute-barred, that the plaintiffs lacked the locus standi to institute it, and that it disclosed no reasonable cause of action.

It also accused the plaintiffs of abusing court process and failing to comply with the mandatory written deposition requirement under Paragraph 7(1) of the Federal High Court Pre-Election Practice Directions (Amendment) 2026.

INEC further questioned the propriety of Reliefs 2 and 3 in the originating summons and asked the court to dismiss the case.

Meanwhile, following an agreement among counsel to the parties, Justice Ekwo fixed December 2 for the hearing of the substantive suit.

The dismissal of the application does not, in itself, determine the substantive allegations against Tinubu, which remain before the court for adjudication.

CAPIS

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here
Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!